VIP flapping/fluctuation between 2 load balancers

gnizamuddin — Mon, 15 Oct 2012 08:18:04 GMT

I have 2 load balancers which are supposed to work in active-standy fashion. The load balancers had been working fine till last 2 days (for a couple of years). However, I faced an outage because of continuous VIP flapping on these load balancers on Saturday. This VIP is the default gateway for my servers; hence because of flapping the load balanced services were inaccessible for these servers. I could only see these messages in logs:

LPKPK11# sh log sys.log

sys.log OCT 13 19:49:38 4200058

sys.log.prev NOV 12 21:07:38 9999963

LPKPK11# sh log sys.log

OLD LOG MESSAGES HAVE BEEN SAVED in associated .prev file.

NOV 12 21:07:34 1/1 1425645 IPV4-4: Duplicate IP address detected: 172.16.13.5 68-ef-bd-a0-ad-ba

NOV 12 21:07:34 1/1 1425646 IPV4-4: Duplicate IP address detected: 172.16.13.5 68-ef-bd-a0-ad-ba

NOV 12 21:07:34 1/1 1425647 IPV4-4: Duplicate IP address detected: 172.16.13.5 68-ef-bd-a0-ad-ba

NOV 12 21:07:34 1/1 1425648 IPV4-4: Duplicate IP address detected: 172.16.13.5 68-ef-bd-a0-ad-ba

NOV 12 21:07:34 1/1 1425649 IPV4-4: Duplicate IP address detected: 172.16.13.5 68-ef-bd-a0-ad-ba

NOV 12 21:07:34 1/1 1425650 IPV4-4: Duplicate IP address detected: 172.16.13.5 68-ef-bd-a0-ad-ba

No virtual router was being seen by both load balancers:

LPKPK11# sh redundant-vips

Redundant-Vips:

Interface Address: 172.16.13.5 VRID: 31

Redundant Address: 172.16.13.27 Range: 1

State: No Virtual Router Master IP: 172.16.13.5

State Changes: 3,562 Last Change: 10/13/2012 19:45:35

Interface Address: 172.16.197.122 VRID: 10

Redundant Address: 172.16.197.81 Range: 1

State: No Virtual Router Master IP: 172.16.197.122

State Changes: 3,563 Last Change: 10/13/2012 19:45:35

Interface Address: 172.16.197.122 VRID: 10

Redundant Address: 172.16.197.82 Range: 1

State: No Virtual Router Master IP: 172.16.197.122

State Changes: 3,563 Last Change: 10/13/2012 19:45:35

Interface Address: 172.16.197.122 VRID: 10

Redundant Address: 172.16.197.84 Range: 1

State: No Virtual Router Master IP: 172.16.197.122

State Changes: 3,563 Last Change: 10/13/2012 19:45:35

Interface Address: 172.16.197.122 VRID: 10

Redundant Address: 172.16.197.85 Range: 1

State: No Virtual Router Master IP: 172.16.197.122

State Changes: 3,563 Last Change: 10/13/2012 19:45:35

CPU and memory status was normal:

# sh system-resources

System Resources for CSS501-SCM-INT:

Installed Memory: 268,435,456 (256 MB)

Free Memory: 137,464,384 (131 MB)

CPU: 0% (5Sec) 5% (1Min) 3% (5Min)

Buffer Statistics:

Buffer Pool: 0

Size:2048 Total:3072 Available:2776 Failures: 0 Low Buffer Count: 2084

Buffer Pool: 1

Size:2048 Total:3072 Available:2832 Failures: 0 Low Buffer Count: 2832

Buffer Pool: 2

Size:2048 Total:2048 Available:1944 Failures: 0 Low Buffer Count: 1856

I observed preempt (but with different priority) on different Circuit VIPs on both LBs which I turned off on secondary LB. The problem didn't resolve.

I turned off the critical services. That also didn't help.

I rebooted both LBs; but also in vain.

Eventually, I had to shut down one LB to restore the service. Here are the IP configs on both LBs:

LB1:

===

!************************* INTERFACE *************************

interface e1

bridge vlan 31

interface e2

description "Signaling uplink on LPKPK11 towards S9309-A1 Eth-1/0/33"

bridge vlan 40

interface e5

description "Inter-CCS Communication towards other LB Master-Slave Mode"

isc-port-one

interface e6

description "Inter-CCS Communication towards other LB Master-Slave Mode"

isc-port-two

interface e7

trunk

vlan 2

vlan 3

interface e8

description "to SW11-Gi0/18"

bridge vlan 3

!************************** CIRCUIT **************************

circuit VLAN31

ip address 172.16.13.5 255.255.255.0

ip virtual-router 31 priority 110 preempt

ip redundant-interface 31 172.16.13.4

ip redundant-vip 31 172.16.13.27

ip critical-service 31 upstream_downstream

circuit VLAN3

ip address 172.16.197.122 255.255.255.192

ip virtual-router 10 priority 110 preempt

ip redundant-interface 10 172.16.197.120

ip redundant-vip 10 172.16.197.85

ip redundant-vip 10 172.16.197.84

ip redundant-vip 10 172.16.197.81

ip redundant-vip 10 172.16.197.82

ip critical-service 10 upstream_downstream

circuit VLAN40

ip address 172.31.96.5 255.255.255.240

ip virtual-router 40 priority 110 preempt

ip redundant-interface 40 172.31.96.4

LB2:

===

!************************* INTERFACE *************************

interface e1

bridge vlan 31

interface e2

description "Signaling uplink on LPKPK12 towards S9309-A2 Eth-1/0/33"

bridge vlan 40

interface e5

description "Inter-CCS Communication towards other LB Master-Slave Mode"

isc-port-one

interface e6

description "Inter-CCS Communication towards other LB Master-Slave Mode"

isc-port-two

interface e7

trunk

vlan 2

vlan 3

interface e8

bridge vlan 3

!************************** CIRCUIT **************************

circuit VLAN31

ip address 172.16.13.7 255.255.255.0

ip virtual-router 31 priority 90

ip redundant-interface 31 172.16.13.4

ip redundant-vip 31 172.16.13.27

ip critical-service 31 upstream_downstream

circuit VLAN3

ip address 172.16.197.121 255.255.255.192

ip virtual-router 10 priority 90

ip redundant-interface 10 172.16.197.120

ip redundant-vip 10 172.16.197.85

ip redundant-vip 10 172.16.197.84

ip redundant-vip 10 172.16.197.81

ip redundant-vip 10 172.16.197.82

ip critical-service 10 upstream_downstream

circuit VLAN40

ip address 172.31.96.6 255.255.255.240

ip virtual-router 40 priority 90

ip redundant-interface 40 172.31.96.4

I need urgent help from Cisco CSS experts here. Awaiting for your kind feedback.

Regards

Nizam

VIP flapping/fluctuation between 2 load balancers

chrhiggi — Mon, 15 Oct 2012 20:53:05 GMT

Nizam-

Depends on what code you are running....but sounds like a match for CSCek37489 where the standby CSS forgets it is supposed to be standby after 828 days of uptime.

Regards,

Chris Higgins

Cisco ANS TAC Escalation

VIP flapping/fluctuation between 2 load balancers

gnizamuddin — Tue, 16 Oct 2012 05:44:59 GMT

Thanks Chris. Can you send me a reference for this bug's fix?

Also, I rebooted both load balancers but the problem prevailed. If the problem is due to this bug, the reboot should have refreshed the uptime counter of both load balancers and the problem should have been fixed.

Nizam

VIP flapping/fluctuation between 2 load balancers

chrhiggi — Wed, 17 Oct 2012 22:49:07 GMT

Symptom:

Backup CSS may send VRRP packets suddenly and then both CSSes goes Master status.

Conditions:

This symptom is observed on CSS that runs about 828 days.

Workaround:

Rebooting the CSS.

Fixed-In:

7.50(3.3)

8.10(2.5)

8.20(0.1)

5.0(6.16)S

7.50(2.11)S

8.10(1.11)S

6.10(4.18)S

7.40(3.9)S

topic VIP flapping/fluctuation between 2 load balancers in Application Networking

VIP flapping/fluctuation between 2 load balancers

VIP flapping/fluctuation between 2 load balancers

VIP flapping/fluctuation between 2 load balancers

VIP flapping/fluctuation between 2 load balancers