topic Re: Sharing IP-SGT-Mappings between Switches with inline propagation in Network Access Control

Sharing IP-SGT-Mappings between Switches with inline propagation

rmueller@cisco.com — Fri, 03 Aug 2018 09:58:32 GMT

Hi all,

I have a maybe basic question about SGACL-enforcement locally on access switches:

Let’s assume I have two access-switches within a L2-deployment (Access-Switch A and Access-Switch B).

On Access-Switch A User_a is being authenticated, he get’s SGT 10. The switch downloads SGACL for SGT 10 from ISE, and the switch also has the SGT-to-ip mapping for User_a.

On Access-Switch B User_b is being authenticated, he get’s SGT 20. The switch downloads SGACL for SGT 20 from ISE, and the switch also has the SGT-to-ip mapping for User_b.

Propagation method is inline tagging.

Now the SGACL denies communication between SGT 10 and SGT 20. If the packet now is sourced on access-switch A, how does access-switch A know about the SGT-to-ip mapping for User_b, which is stored locally on switch B?

Thanks in advance.

Roland

Re: Sharing IP-SGT-Mappings between Switches with inline propagation

jeaves@cisco.com — Fri, 03 Aug 2018 10:33:27 GMT

Hi Roland,

it doesn't know of the remote mapping.

Remember that the technology is built for egress enforcement.

So, traffic flows from A to B, the A side doesn't know of the B mapping so there can't be any enforcement on the A side for this flow. However, switch A inserts the source SGT into the L2 frame (inline propagation) for the packets sent to B. The B switch reads the source SGT off the wire, has the destination SGT and can enforce.

So, egress enforcement on B.

In the other direction it's the same - egress enforcement at A.

If you want/need to do ingress enforcement then you have to propagate the destination mappings back to the source (using something like SXP) but that doesn't scale.

Cheers, Jonothan.

Re: Sharing IP-SGT-Mappings between Switches with inline propagation

rmueller@cisco.com — Mon, 06 Aug 2018 15:20:30 GMT

Jonathan,

thank you very much - this explains it!

Roland