topic Re: ISE 2.4 CWA integration with Aruba Controller | Maximum Simultaneous Sessions Logins per guest user does not work properly in Network Access Control

ISE 2.4 CWA integration with Aruba Controller | Maximum Simultaneous Sessions Logins per guest user does not work properly

SHABEEB KUNHIPOCKER — Tue, 20 Nov 2018 11:02:40 GMT

Hello,

I have a customer who has Aruba WLAN integrated with ISE 2.4 (patch 4) for CWA. The customer has a requirement that a guest can register maximum 2 devices and at a time he should only login from one device. I tried to use " disconnect oldest connection" in the guest, but found that there is no COA being generated from ISE. Then I tried the "disconnect newest connection" which is working in a random manner. When it works I am able to see COA success message in the radius live logs. When it does not work I am getting COA failed message in live logs with error-cause as " Session Context Not Found". Did anyone came across the same scenario?. Kindly help.

Re: ISE 2.4 CWA integration with Aruba Controller | Maximum Simultaneous Sessions Logins per guest user does not work properly

Jason Kunst — Tue, 20 Nov 2018 12:31:04 GMT

I have heard about this but would need tac to troubleshoot as well

Likely Aruba controller issue buggy.

Have they tried with Cisco controller?

Re: ISE 2.4 CWA integration with Aruba Controller | Maximum Simultaneous Sessions Logins per guest user does not work properly

SHABEEB KUNHIPOCKER — Tue, 20 Nov 2018 13:04:22 GMT

I believe it is of limitation for ISE to work to third party NAD. The Aruba controller is working as expected. They did not try with Cisco Controller. I have a TAC case opened and they said they registered a software defect for the " disconnect oldest connection" issue. But for " disconnect newest connection" till now there is no solution.

Re: ISE 2.4 CWA integration with Aruba Controller | Maximum Simultaneous Sessions Logins per guest user does not work properly

Jason Kunst — Tue, 20 Nov 2018 17:12:12 GMT

you have an internal thread going on as well. will follow up and see how we can work together. please continue working through tac

Re: ISE 2.4 CWA integration with Aruba Controller | Maximum Simultaneous Sessions Logins per guest user does not work properly

Arne Bier — Tue, 20 Nov 2018 21:33:17 GMT

Does the Aruba controller send Radius Accounting to ISE? I would imagine that the Aruba controller has nothing to do with this fault at all because the CoA is not initiated by it. If ISE does not send out a CoA then that is not the fault of the NAS.

ISE needs to maintain session state somehow and that's the part that's gone skew. Hence the question about Radius Accounting. Session management is so fundamental to any good Radius server and I don't recall ever seeoing a decent explanation of how this is done in ISE. If there is a good technical discussion about it then I'd like to know. it's like a magic black box.

Re: ISE 2.4 CWA integration with Aruba Controller | Maximum Simultaneous Sessions Logins per guest user does not work properly

SHABEEB KUNHIPOCKER — Wed, 21 Nov 2018 05:10:56 GMT

Hi Arne,

Aruba controller do send the radius accouting to ISE. I can see that in the packet capture. I agree with you that the fault is not at the NAS side since CoA is a Radius server functionality. For the "oldest connection issue" the TAC told me that the session-id attribute for the oldest connection is not availble in the MNT node and thus ISE is not able to initiate a CoA. I am still waiting for their response. Actually the guest network is pretty big and due to this issue the customer has asked to hold the migration until the fix is given by the TAC.