topic Re: ACI Ansible Role AEP Domain Link Error in Controllers

ACI Ansible Role AEP Domain Link Error

AJ Cruz — Thu, 23 Apr 2020 16:15:56 GMT

I'm not sure if this is the right area to post this, but has anyone played with the ACI Ansible role from Code Exchange?: https://developer.cisco.com/codeexchange/github/repo/datacenter/ansible-role-aci-model

I modified it to build an ACI topology in my home lab using the ACI Simulator. Everything works perfectly except linking AEPs to Domains.

Here's my Ansible inventory, AEP/Domain sections:

- aep:
        - name: External-AAEP
          domain:
          - name: L3-Ext-Dom
        - name: Phys-AAEP
          domain:
          - name: Phys-Dom
      - external_routed_domain:
        - name: L3-Ext-Dom
          vlan_pool: Phys-VLAN-Pool
          vlan_pool_alloc: static
      - physical_domain:
        - name: Phys-Dom
          vlan_pool: Phys-VLAN-Pool
          vlan_pool_alloc: static

When I run the Ansible playbook I get this:

failed: [apic1 -> localhost] (item={'access_policy_aep_name': 'External-AAEP', 'access_policy_aep_domain_name': 'L3-Ext-Dom'}) => {"ansible_loop_var": "item", "changed": false, "error": {"code": "120", "text": "unknown property value uni/infra/attentp-External-AAEP/rsdomP-[uni/L3-Ext-Dom], name dn, class infraRsDomP [(Dn0)] Dn0=, "}, "item": {"access_policy_aep_domain_name": "L3-Ext-Dom", "access_policy_aep_name": "External-AAEP"}, "msg": "APIC Error 120: unknown property value uni/infra/attentp-External-AAEP/rsdomP-[uni/L3-Ext-Dom], name dn, class infraRsDomP [(Dn0)] Dn0=, ", "status": -1}
failed: [apic1 -> localhost] (item={'access_policy_aep_name': 'Phys-AAEP', 'access_policy_aep_domain_name': 'Phys-Dom'}) => {"ansible_loop_var": "item", "changed": false, "error": {"code": "120", "text": "unknown property value uni/infra/attentp-Phys-AAEP/rsdomP-[uni/Phys-Dom], name dn, class infraRsDomP [(Dn0)] Dn0=, "}, "item": {"access_policy_aep_domain_name": "Phys-Dom", "access_policy_aep_name": "Phys-AAEP"}, "msg": "APIC Error 120: unknown property value uni/infra/attentp-Phys-AAEP/rsdomP-[uni/Phys-Dom], name dn, class infraRsDomP [(Dn0)] Dn0=, ", "status": -1}

Any ideas? Thanks!

Re: ACI Ansible Role AEP Domain Link Error

Sergiu.Daniluk — Thu, 23 Apr 2020 17:47:42 GMT

Hi @AJ Cruz

I noticed the same problem. There are some problems there because the role is using aci_rest module, an there are some limitations there, for example: you have multiple types of existing domains (example phys, l3domains as you have in your inventory file), and each have a different format for the DN. But in the role there is only a task which creates phy domains using aci_rest. So you either have to create multiple tasks for each type of domain, either, change most of tasks from the role, as I did, with existing specific modules. Here is how i changed it:

In the Inventory I added type attribute for domains:

      - aep:
        - name: ansible_aep
          domain:
          - name: ansible_phydom
            type: phys
          - name: ansible_l3dom
            type: l3dom

In the role, I changed aci_rest with aci_aep_to_domain:

  - name: Link AEPs to domains
    aci_aep_to_domain:
      <<: *aci_login
      aep: '{{ item.access_policy_aep_name }}'
      domain: '{{ item.access_policy_aep_domain_name }}'
      domain_type: '{{ item.access_policy_aep_domain_type }}'
    with_items: '{{ aci_model_data|aci_listify("access_policy","aep", "domain") }}'

Much cleaner and nicer. Of course, not all existing objects have dedicated modules (mostly related to L3Out), but if is there, why not use it.

I will update my project soon on github. You will find there a role for standalone Nexus switches as well.

Hope it helps,

Sergiu

Re: ACI Ansible Role AEP Domain Link Error

AJ Cruz — Thu, 23 Apr 2020 18:09:04 GMT

Thanks, I see it now, when I intercept the POST from creating the link in the GUI I noticed either a "uni/phys-" or a "uni/l3out-" in the tDn.

I'll re-structure the inventory as you suggested to fix that.

Thanks!

Re: ACI Ansible Role AEP Domain Link Error

Claudia de Luna — Thu, 23 Apr 2020 18:50:22 GMT

Hi @AJ Cruz ,

Looks like this is an older role.

I have found that as ACI matures some subtle changes occur as the MIT gets enhanced and on occasion changed.

Looks like the role is balking at rsdomP.

"msg": "APIC Error 120: unknown property value uni/infra/attentp-Phys-AAEP/rsdomP-[uni/Phys-Dom], name dn, class infraRsDomP [(Dn0)] Dn0=, ",

which, if you look at the actual post URI and payload (below) wants infraRsDomP.

I actually can't get a clean run of this repo on my simulator but mine fails on other objects.

I'll fiddle with it and report back.

FWIW I have always found it much easier to work with the act_rest module if I'm using Ansible. In truth I never use Ansible to build out the fabric (but it is handy for ongoing operations so good to learn for sure).

url: https: //10.1.10.111/api/node/mo/uni/infra/attentp-EXTERNAL-AAEP.json
	payload {
		"infraRsDomP": {
			"attributes": {
				"tDn": "uni/l3dom-L3-Ext-Dom",
				"status": "created,modified"
			},
			"children": []
		}
	}

Re: ACI Ansible Role AEP Domain Link Error

Claudia de Luna — Thu, 23 Apr 2020 18:51:30 GMT

LOL! Sergiu beat me to it and his solution is far more helpful than mine!

Good luck!

Re: ACI Ansible Role AEP Domain Link Error

AJ Cruz — Thu, 21 May 2020 15:10:58 GMT

I converted all the raw rest calls to use native ansible modules, restructured the topology file a bit, and made a small change to the jinja filter to allow it to accept a list as a value (for listing leaves when adding static paths).

Here it is: https://github.com/aj-cruz/aci-ansible-role.git