topic Re: Error updating a policy with APIC-EM API in Controllers

Error updating a policy with APIC-EM API

andreizamfir16 — Fri, 01 Mar 2019 12:28:44 GMT

Hello! I'm trying to use the APIC-EM and its API to update a policy, but I get the error "BadRequest", with failureReason "Invalid Policy". The body I'm using in the PUT request is the following json:

[

{

"instanceUuid":"a298dfd7-1a21-4ab5-a223-df415906a681",

"policyName":"Test-Policy-1_BR",

"policyOwner":"devnetuser",

"policyPriority":4095,

"state":"Active",

"taskId":"f3a40f1d-a675-4cb8-acec-41b0625ac161",

"id":"96348dc5-a760-4ce3-9ee8-28b349ba6618",

"resource":{

"applications":[

{

"appName":"ptp",

"id":"0661d06e-99ad-41b6-93e0-e36ff02029af"

{

"appName":"twitch-tv",

"id":"019d6ce9-8e40-401c-9b11-14483d7d5f7d"

{

"appName":"distcc",

"id":"01b823bd-9a18-4891-8eed-8d40c2016abe"

{

"appName":"directv-soft",

"id":"012ac649-a306-4c0c-9098-da00bc91d510"

{

"appName":"windows-store",

"id":"00d2d0d4-1b31-43ff-845e-f4f1f0fd7b07"

}

]

"actions":[

"SET_PROPERTY"

"policyScope":"Test-Policy-1",

"actionProperty":{

"relevanceLevel":"Business-Rrelevant",

"pathControlFlag":false,

"pathPreferenceFlag":false

}

]

The json I'm getting as processing the task is this one:

{

"response":{

"startTime":1465576395397,

"endTime":1465576395403,

"progress":"Policy Update Failed",

"version":1465576395397,

"errorCode":"BadRequest",

"serviceType":"Policy Service",

"operationIdList":[

"669ea643-04ad-478e-abe9-322dc775e872"

"isError":true,

"failureReason":"Invalid Policy",

"rootId":"30e589a3-613c-4184-a681-6378cd201de0",

"id":"30e589a3-613c-4184-a681-6378cd201de0"

"version":"1.0"

}

Also, while trying to update a policy with this body:

[
   {
      "instanceUuid":"a298dfd7-1a21-4ab5-a223-df415906a681",
      "policyName":"Test-Policy-1_IR",
      "policyOwner":"devnetuser",
      "policyPriority":4095,
      "state":"Active",
      "taskId":"9f3f7ece-10e8-4e9b-9476-c96b8280d343",
      "id":"a298dfd7-1a21-4ab5-a223-df415906a681",
      "resource":{
         "applications":[
            {
               "appName":"wordreference-com",
               "id":"218c7242-9455-42b8-aaf9-5e65f7a322ca"
            },
            {
               "appName":"smakynet",
               "id":"04fa6934-6e42-496a-93e6-1f5e4ccb464d"
            }
         ]
      },
      "actions":[
         "SET_PROPERTY"
      ],
      "policyScope":"Test-Policy-1",
      "actionProperty":{
         "relevanceLevel":"Business-Irrelevant",
         "pathControlFlag":false,
         "pathPreferenceFlag":false
      }
   }
]

I get this response:

{

"response":{

"startTime":1465577653334,

"endTime":1465577653415,

"progress":"Policy Update Failed",

"version":1465577653334,

"errorCode":"ResourceConflict",

"serviceType":"Policy Service",

"operationIdList":[

"360966c9-0306-47b9-94c8-7972e39f13e0"

"isError":true,

"failureReason":"Policy Conflict",

"rootId":"9eadc2d0-0eaf-4da0-92a6-71f86110ee20",

"id":"9eadc2d0-0eaf-4da0-92a6-71f86110ee20"

"version":"1.0"

}, having errorCode "ResourceConflict" and failureReason "Policy Conflict".

Any ideas what those errors mean?

Re: Error updating a policy with APIC-EM API

yawming — Mon, 13 Jun 2016 18:47:37 GMT

Are you doing this from your network or Cisco DevNet Sandbox ?

Re: Error updating a policy with APIC-EM API

andreizamfir16 — Mon, 13 Jun 2016 18:49:40 GMT

I'm trying to update the policy from the Cisco DevNet Sandbox.

Re: Error updating a policy with APIC-EM API

yawming — Mon, 13 Jun 2016 22:07:39 GMT

Cisco DevNet Sandbox Always On or reserved ?

Your POST policy has no error tight ? Can you please share your JSON for POST ?

You know that Always On Lab is using Data Base, not really connect to live network right ? So we can create a policy but cannot really activate the policy.

Re: Error updating a policy with APIC-EM API

andreizamfir16 — Mon, 13 Jun 2016 22:25:54 GMT

I think it's not reserved and yes, I know that. I just want to demonstrate how you can create and update policies. This is the POST json:

[

{

"policyName":"Test-Policy_D",

"policyOwner":"devnetuser",

"policyPriority":4095,

"resource":{

"applications":[

{

"appName":"avian",

"id":"05bafa0b-63ab-4a73-9a95-0a12cf9156cd"

}

]

"actions":[

"SET_PROPERTY"

"policyScope":"Test-Policy",

"actionProperty":{

"relevanceLevel":"Default"

}

]

Re: Error updating a policy with APIC-EM API

yawming — Tue, 14 Jun 2016 19:00:46 GMT

Works fine with me

first I use get policy and select "Test-Policy" from existing policy to modify

the response from "GET policy"

{

"instanceUuid": "1321f81e-acda-4830-8882-f434ace91231",

"policyPriority": 4095,

"policyName": "Test-Policy_BR",

"actionProperty": {

"pathPreferenceFlag": false,

"relevanceLevel": "Business-Relevant",

"pathControlFlag": false

"actions": [

"SET_PROPERTY"

"state": "Active",

"policyScope": "Test-Policy",

"taskId": "47b1e3e9-4b6e-423a-b007-3230b5f8a36d",

"id": "1321f81e-acda-4830-8882-f434ace91231",

"policyOwner": "devnetuser",

"resource": {

"applications": [

{

"appName": "twitch-tv",

"id": "019d6ce9-8e40-401c-9b11-14483d7d5f7d"

{

"appName": "sntp-heartbeat",

"id": "02d81471-2c4f-497d-b000-f6ae3e32c96f"

}

]

}

I just change "policyPriority": 4095 to "policyPriority": 4099 so here is my JSON

[{

"id": "1321f81e-acda-4830-8882-f434ace91231",

"policyPriority": 4999,

"policyName": "Test-Policy_BR",

"actionProperty": {

"relevanceLevel": "Business-Relevant",

"actions": [

"SET_PROPERTY"

"state": "Active",

"policyScope": "Test-Policy",

"policyOwner": "devnetuser",

"resource": {

"applications": [

{

"appName": "twitch-tv",

"id": "019d6ce9-8e40-401c-9b11-14483d7d5f7d"

{

"appName": "sntp-heartbeat",

"id": "02d81471-2c4f-497d-b000-f6ae3e32c96f"

}

]

}

}]

Here is the result of PUT task, no error.

{

"response": {

	"startTime": 1465930102747,
	"endTime": 1465930102955,
	"version": 1465930102747,
	"serviceType": "Policy Service",
	"operationIdList": [
	"49a4da31-3649-4746-95e7-19f583a21656"
	],
	"isError": false,
	"rootId": "632eefa4-7754-43ad-be94-b7bb97c647cb",
	"id": "632eefa4-7754-43ad-be94-b7bb97c647cb"

"version": "1.0"

}

The I did the GET policy again. From the response we can see the policyPriority changed to 4999

{

"actions": [

"SET_PROPERTY"

"state": "Active",

"policyOwner": "devnetuser",

"resource": {

"applications": [

{

"appName": "twitch-tv",

"id": "019d6ce9-8e40-401c-9b11-14483d7d5f7d"

{

"appName": "sntp-heartbeat",

"id": "02d81471-2c4f-497d-b000-f6ae3e32c96f"

}

]

"instanceUuid": "1321f81e-acda-4830-8882-f434ace91231",

"taskId": "632eefa4-7754-43ad-be94-b7bb97c647cb",

"actionProperty": {

"relevanceLevel": "Business-Relevant",

"pathPreferenceFlag": false,

"pathControlFlag": false

"id": "1321f81e-acda-4830-8882-f434ace91231",

"policyName": "Test-Policy_BR",

"policyPriority": 4999,

"policyScope": "Test-Policy"

}

Re: Error updating a policy with APIC-EM API

andreizamfir16 — Sun, 19 Jun 2016 13:20:54 GMT

It's still the same for me.. Sometimes it works, sometimes I get "Invalid Policy" as an answer and sometimes it's "Policy Conflict" as failureReason. What should I do?

Re: Error updating a policy with APIC-EM API

yawming — Sun, 19 Jun 2016 21:58:07 GMT

Policy Conflict may due to duplicate of policy name or something else. I think "Invalid Policy" is a little bit more difficult to find the reason. Sometime I got this that "I think" APIC-EM doesn't like the JSON object. It will be nice if APIC-EM can point out where it went wrong.

"Sometime it works, sometime not", were you using the same JSON or different JSON to try ?

BTW which version of Sandbox you're using ? 1.1 - sandboxapic.cisco.com:9443 ? or 1.2 - sandboxapic.cisco.com ?

Re: Error updating a policy with APIC-EM API

andreizamfir16 — Mon, 20 Jun 2016 19:02:36 GMT

Yes I think it's hard to find the reason too! I'm using Sandbox version 1.2 and I'm developing a demo app that uses the APIC-EM api. It works fine if I POST a policy and update it (for example the Business Irrelevant part of the policy). It still works if I POST another policy (for example, the Business Relevant part of the policy) and update. But if I switch back to the first policy and try to update it, it doesn't work anymore. The code should work, it doesn't have a problem.