topic Re: getDeviceSwitchPortsStatusesPackets - counters seems strange in Network Platform API

getDeviceSwitchPortsStatusesPackets - counters seems strange

Yaakov Neuman at NetOp AI — Thu, 06 Feb 2025 18:08:29 GMT

I'm trying to understand the way the API `getDeviceSwitchPortsStatusesPackets` works.

I found this topic https://community.meraki.com/t5/Developers-APIs/How-frequently-are-switch-port-status-packets-updated/m-p/76423 which says the counter are updated about every 5m.

I run a script which send request with timespan=900 for 5 times, with 15m delay between them (total time is 1h).

Right after it finish, the scripts run request with timespan of 1500, 1800, 2100, 2400, 2700, 3000, 3600.

Here is the results of the total counters from my lab:

Total Sent Received
-------- ------ ------ ----------

900 #1 4208 2677 1531
900 #2 4283 2726 1557
900 #3 4197 2704 1493
900 #4 3807 2479 1328

900 #5 4201 2679 1522

1500 25m 3989 2622 1367
1800 30m 3989 2622 1367
2100 35m 3989 2622 1367
2400 40m 15755 10293 5462
2700 45m 15755 10293 5462
3000 50m 15755 10293 5462
3600 60m 15755 10293 5462

I expected that the [1800 30m] will the summarize of [900 #4] and [900 #5], but it doesn't. It's not even close. Pay attention that the last [2100 35m] are less than the last 15m [900 #5]. Is it possible!?

I expected that the [3600 60m] will the summarize of [900 #2] till [900 #5], but it doesn't. It close, but not exactly.

I tested it several times, and it always strange.

Am I missing something?

Re: getDeviceSwitchPortsStatusesPackets - counters seems strange

sungod — Thu, 06 Feb 2025 18:46:04 GMT

We know it's not realtime data, but some cached values held in Dashboard, perhaps in 5 minute buckets.

The switches will be reporting the Dashboard at some rate/latency, but that timing is not specified in the documentation.

Is it the switches that update Dashboard strictly every 5 minutes? or is it that Dashboard gets data from switches 'whenever', and updates the bucket values ever five minutes? how big are the buckets? are they aligned to some epoch? or do they wobble around? It's unclear.

In general I find it best not to rely on data for a recent point in time, or for any short period of time, like less than hours, as there's too much uncertainly, mainly due to lack of precise definitions in the documentation.

But as you are getting a response that less happened between now and 35 minutes ago, than happened in a 15 minute sub-interval of that 35 minutes, it seems like reason to open a support case!

Re: getDeviceSwitchPortsStatusesPackets - counters seems strange

Yaakov Neuman at NetOp AI — Thu, 06 Feb 2025 21:03:24 GMT

Thanks for the answer.

So actually, do you recommend to use this API only once for a hour?

In the beginning I thought to use it every 30m.

If only Meraki could support intervals for those counters... 😞

By the way, I forgot to mention that I'm using REST API, not the meraki package. Does it matter?

p.s. I'm new here. Is there a guide how to open a support case?

Re: getDeviceSwitchPortsStatusesPackets - counters seems strange

sungod — Fri, 07 Feb 2025 11:33:23 GMT

I've not used that endpoint, but I'd guess it's like others where using shorter time periods can sometimes give odd numbers.

Using endpoints direct or with the library should make no difference, the library is just a 'wrapper' around the same endpoints.

You open a support case from the Dashboard... click on ? at the top-right of the page, click "Get help & cases", click on the "API and webhooks" button, and there's a button on that page to submit a case.