Recently there were quite a few blog posts on VPN forums relating to troubleshooting common issues in IPsec VPN.
Ankur & others have posted a few nice articles.
I do find, however, that to troubleshoot core issues of IPsec VPN - be it a mis-configuration or a bug - you need to know how the protocol works.
And even if you do, different devices behave differently and provide different outputs.
What have I been up to
Over the course of last few months I have been trying to make it easy for wannabe troubleshooters to diagnose and enable to correct themselves common issues of IPsec VPN.
To do this however, let's recap what you should know about IKE
High level view of IKE version 1 exchange
As many of you know IKE version 1 has following modes:
- Aggressive mode
- Main mode
Aggressive mode is typically used for EzVPN when using pre-shared key (PSK).
Main mode is the mode we use when establishing Lan-to-Lan/DMVPN/SVTI tunnels or ezvpn with use of certificates.
Note that I refer to messages below, not packets. This is a common misconception, a message might need multiple packets to be sent.
Aggressive mode needs 3 messages to establish phase 1 association and additional 3 to establish IPsec SA to be able to pass traffic (called Quick Mode - QM).
Main mode exchanges 6 messages to establish phase 1 and again additional 3 messages to finish Quick Mode - same way as in aggressive mode.
The main advantage of main mode is that it is more secure. Aggressive mode will exchange your pre-shared key in a hashed form, but not encrypted. That is why to improve security users are required also to provide their username and password.
Result of my work.
The result of my work is a few articles to cover the most common deployments.
The intention is to help troubleshooters map CLI commands to messages in debugging and vice versa, understanding how messages in debugging map to configuration.
The documents will also serve as reference for people who would like to know how successful debugging session looks like.
Based on them you might be able to find where your session breaks.
Hopefully this help of those they will be able to spot problems without involving TAC. ;-)
Does anyone have any experience in bringing up a VPN connection between an ASR1001-X and Meraki? We're unable to establish the VPN tunnel if traffic is initiated from our side (ASR1001-X) but the tunnel comes up if traffic is initiated from the Mera...
Just wondering if anyone has seen issues with Win10 and WIRED posture. We have seen random issues with posture where clients say compliant but they are still have the redirect ACL on wired session. When looking at the logs, we see a machine go...
Hello All,So we have a scenario, where we are supposed to initialize ISE setup in Test environment with production IP address and then ship it for Customer's Production environment. I have heard about NTP sync failure after this process.Logically this app...
Hello, We upgraded our 5505 to a 5506 with FirePower to take advantage of the increased bandwidth and the FirePower Services for security. Previously we had extensive object groups for access and denial and we wanted to transition...
I'm wondering if I can build a policy for authentication that will perform dot1x first, give it five seconds or so as a window to successfuly pass 802.1x auth, and then if dot1x does not succeed in that time, start a MAB authentication transaction.