Ok, after reading this forum, and several others, I got port forwarding working, Sort Of.
It doesn't work the way I want it to, or that it used to with a different router...
I want to forward any incoming traffic on port 8080 to a particular IP address in my lan with a different port.
ie... 8080>> 192.168.1.39:80
Right now I have working
8080 >> 192.168.1.39:8080
Problem is, everything ELSE (on the LAN) expects the server to be on port 80. How do I forward to a DIFFERENT Port #?