cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
422
Views
0
Helpful
0
Replies

L2 vs L3 to access with VSS

brian.kennedy
Level 1
Level 1

This is not really a question - just curious to to the thoughts out there on pushing L3 out to the edge vs L2 when you're running vss?  Some caveats:  VLANs are (generally) restricted to a single port (ie each access switch/idf has it's own vlan, so vlans are not spanned out multiple ports).  Access switches (primarily 4510 or 3750x) are port-channeled to the vss distro's (6509s):

With VSS:

pros to L2:

not dependent on spanning tree

no blocked links

no need for a FHRP.

cost

a vlan can be spanned out multiple ports if needed

cons to L2:

poor man's load-balancing (dependent on your port-channel configuration)

link may be up but not able to pass traffic w/out switch knowing (ie, less intelligence)

pros to L3

true load balancing

quick convergence

troubleshooting - more/better tools for trouble-shooting closer to the edge.

increased QoS functionality

cons to L3

cost - this can get absorbed in a larger closet, but in large campuses, the cost can be substantial

cannot span a vlan to multiple ports

Personally, cost not being issue, I like the idea of running 1q trunking with point-to-point L3, but this also allows a vlan that may need to be spanned to multiple ports if needed.

0 Replies 0