cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
147
Views
0
Helpful
4
Replies

Why are google's sites blacklisted?

foxwolfie
Level 1
Level 1

I have doubleclick.net, billmelater.com and doublepimp.com set to "always block", but nothing else. However, I cannot access certain google sites.  I get OpenDNS pages notifying me that the sites are blocked, with "blacklist" as the reason.

When I go to my stats, and look at "blocked domains", I see the following list:

Rank

       Domain

ReasonRequests
1 www.googleadservices.com Blacklist  177
2 *.doubleclick.net Blacklist  119
3 www.billmelater.com Blacklist  51
4 doublepimp.com Blacklist  14
5 www.googletagservices.com Blacklist  6
6 pagead2.googlesyndication.com Blacklist  2

Why are the three google domains being blocked? They are not in my "always block" list.  Putting them into my "never block" list does not unblock them, even after a browser or computer restart. My IP has not changed in the past nine months, so it's not because of suddenly getting someone else's dynamic IP.  Is there any way to unblock at least the googletagservices.com domain?

 

4 Replies 4

mattwilson9090
Level 4
Level 4

Despite whatever specific services they may offer, Google is an advertising company, and that's where they get the vast bulk of their money from. All of their websites are built around using ads, and getting feedback through various services, scripts, and domains is a big part of all their sites, even if you don't visibly see it.

Over the years they've purchased various ad related companies, such as doubleclick, so it stands to reason that if you block domains that they own, or are related to advertising that you will see an impact on various Google services. It's complicated by the fact that Google uses so many different domains on their various sites, and seems to change them periodically. I haven't checked out the DNS entries for the various domains, but it's entirely possibly that some of them "point" to others as well, which could further complicate things.

Is your only purpose in using OpenDNS to block ads, and that's why you aren't blocking any categories, and instead only blocking those 3 domains?

foxwolfie
Level 1
Level 1
I use OpenDNS because it is more reliable than my ISP's name server. I also like the speed and the small bits of protection it offers. I blocked those three sites because they did things to annoy me too many times. I got tired of billmelater.com constantly nagging me whenever I made an eBay purchase, and blocking the domain completely solved that. Having doubleclick blocked makes browsing on many sites noticeably faster. But, if that is blocking some google sites, I'll probably need to block doubleclick only when I'm browsing on non-google sites. That means shifting that filter over to NoScript, where I can control it better, instead of doing it at the domain level. Personally, I don't mind ads when they are well-behaved, and don't slow things down. If they go out of their way to annoy me, I block them. Thanks for the assistance. I didn't consider that google is starting to own some seemingly unrelated sites that parts of itself might depend on.

rotblitz
Level 6
Level 6

"Why are the three google domains being blocked?"

Because these are aliases (CNAMEs) for real names which are Doubleclick domains:

nslookup  www.googleadservices.com.
Server:  cache0703.ns.eu.uu.net
Address:  193.101.111.20

Nicht autorisierte Antwort:
Name:    pagead.l.doubleclick.net
Addresses:  173.194.113.26, 173.194.113.25, 173.194.113.13
Aliases:  www.googleadservices.com


nslookup  www.googletagservices.com.
Server:  cache0703.ns.eu.uu.net
Address:  193.101.111.20

Nicht autorisierte Antwort:
Name:    pagead46.l.doubleclick.net
Addresses:  173.194.112.45, 173.194.112.57, 173.194.112.58
Aliases:  www.googletagservices.com


nslookup pagead2.googlesyndication.com.
Server:  cache0703.ns.eu.uu.net
Address:  193.101.111.20

Nicht autorisierte Antwort:
Name:    pagead46.l.doubleclick.net
Addresses:  173.194.112.57, 173.194.112.58, 173.194.112.45
Aliases:  pagead2.googlesyndication.com


Try with whitelisting the real names instead of the aliases to see if this helps.  Note that these may be different depending on geographical area, so you must execute the above commands yourself to find them out.

foxwolfie
Level 1
Level 1
Thanks, rotblitz and mattwilson9090. I just blocked doubleclick using NoScript, and added an exception for the domain I needed to work, and removed the block from my OpenDNS. All is fine now. It never even crossed my mind to do a lookup on the sites involved, but I'll keep that in mind if I ever have a blocked domain issue again.