cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
831
Views
7
Helpful
7
Replies

Cannot configure SGBP through a stack of routers

hammoudatunisia
Level 1
Level 1

Dear Cisco community,

I can't configure SGBP  (Stack Group Bidding Protocol) with 2 routers. the topology is simple:

ROUTER1------int F0/0------------int F0/0-----ROUTER2

ROUTER1 configuration:

aaa new-model

username mystack password cisco

hostname ROUTER1

sgbp group mystack

sgbp member ROUTER2  10.1.1.2

sgbp ppp-forward

int F0/0

ip address 10.1.1.1  255.255.255.0

ROUTER2 configuration:

aaa new-model

username mystack password cisco

hostname ROUTER2

sgbp group mystack

sgbp member ROUTER1  10.1.1.1

int F0/0

ip address 10.1.1.2  255.255.255.0

I keep getting this ugly message:  ( %SGBP-3-INVALIDADDR: Stack group mystack IP address 10.1.1.1  )  on ROUTER2

Someone can help please.

Thank you.

Mohamed Nidhal Beyrem Jaziri
CCIE Routing & Switching 38232   

Tunisia  

Mohamed Nidhal Beyrem Jaziri CCIE Routing & Switching 38232 Tunisia
1 Accepted Solution

Accepted Solutions

Hello Giuseppe

Thank for your reply , I am a fan of your posts  but I think that I posted in the right forum because SGBP is a part of Multichassis Multilink PPP (MMP) which is related to VPDN and L2TP technologies. I resolved the problem when I linked the routers with a serial link instead of an Ethernet link. I've got the active state between the 2 routers and everything is alright now. Thank you very much.

Mohamed Nidhal Beyrem Jaziri
CCIE Routing & Switching 38232

Mohamed Nidhal Beyrem Jaziri CCIE Routing & Switching 38232 Tunisia

View solution in original post

7 Replies 7

Giuseppe Larosa
Hall of Fame
Hall of Fame

Hello Mohamed,

because this is a VOIP related topic you should post it under unified communications > IP Telephony or Service Providers > VOIP in order to get better help. Here only Paolo Bevilaqua could be helpful.

note: there is an option to move the thread to another forum

Best Regards

Giuseppe

Hello Giuseppe

Thank for your reply , I am a fan of your posts  but I think that I posted in the right forum because SGBP is a part of Multichassis Multilink PPP (MMP) which is related to VPDN and L2TP technologies. I resolved the problem when I linked the routers with a serial link instead of an Ethernet link. I've got the active state between the 2 routers and everything is alright now. Thank you very much.

Mohamed Nidhal Beyrem Jaziri
CCIE Routing & Switching 38232

Mohamed Nidhal Beyrem Jaziri CCIE Routing & Switching 38232 Tunisia

Hi Hammoudatunisia,

May I have the details on how you solve it?

I'm getting the problem, and I've tried direct Serial Connection.

Same issue.

Please help.

Okay, I've found the cause of the issue.

A few points:

  • I am using GNS3
  • SGBP Generates the Reference Number using the last 8 digits of a BIA MAC Address
  • If both Routers have the same SGBP Reference Number, it won't work
  • Changing the Interface MAC Address will not work, because it is not the Burned In Address (BIA) MAC Address

 

In my case, my GNS3 Routers gave me the following BIA MAC Address:

R1 (bia cc00.b22c.0010) - Ref Number Generated: 0xB22C0010

R2 (bia cc01.b22c.0010) - Ref Number Generated: 0xB22C0010

Both R1 & R2 got the same Ref Number, and therefore the error appeared.

 

Solution 1:

Use a Router model where all modules are removable.

Since Serial Interfaces do not have BIA MAC Addresses, use Serial Interface Modules ONLY.

When the group is created, the following happens:

R1(config)#sgbp group SGBP
ref is 4400000
SGBP Doesn't find a bia to use as reference, self generate one

The self generated one will be random, and it will be usable.

 

Solution 2:

Use a Router model where all modules are removable.

R1, place FE Module in slot 0 only

R2, place FE Module in slot 1 only

R1 Fa0/0 (bia cc00.e3f8.0000) - Ref Number Generated: 0xE3F80000

R2 Fa1/0 (bia cc01.e3f8.0010) - Ref Number Generated: 0xE3F80010

 

Solution 3:

Use 2 different model of Routers to run the SGBP.

This will give different BIA MAC Address for the last 8 digits.

Subeh Sharma
Level 1
Level 1

SGBP is part of Multichassis Multilink PPP so you've posted it in the right forum. This appears to be a bug but i can only confirm once you provide 'show ver' from the router. Also both the router are running the same IOS?

Regards,

Subeh

Thank you my friend, you're right.

Mohamed Nidhal Beyrem Jaziri
CCIE Routing & Switching 38232

Mohamed Nidhal Beyrem Jaziri CCIE Routing & Switching 38232 Tunisia

Giuseppe Larosa
Hall of Fame
Hall of Fame

Hello Mohamed,

I was sure you could solve it by yourself, even if I didn't know much about you ...

Best Regards

Giuseppe

Review Cisco Networking for a $25 gift card