Hi
remember if you create 2 trunk links that are not bundled together of equal cost between 2 switches at the same time stp will block 1 to prevent a loop
you could configure the new sfp trunk keep it shut down , put a high stp cost on the current only trunk link as traffic will still pass , then bring up your new trunk with a lower cost it will take over
or
build them into and etherchannel and then remove the old link
There probably the least service effecting i can think off without shutting down you current link
HTH