cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
387
Views
0
Helpful
2
Replies

Is wireless a viable option over wired?

bhall
Level 1
Level 1

I am located in an 85 year old hospital. Running cable for new PC's is getting very expensive. I currently have 802.11b access points for roaming users. Is the new 802.11G a viable option for a permanent, everyday work PC? Is anyone out there using wireless on desktops? If so, how is 54 Mbit (give or take) working for you?

2 Replies 2

scottmac
Level 10
Level 10

The biggest drawback (IMHO) is that wireless is still a shared media.

You can use workgroup bridges to connect clusters of PCs / printers / etc., or put in wireless NICs in each unit ... the bottom line is still "how much of what kind of traffic " (traffic characteristics).

Wireless will work OK, if you design properly. If you just start dropping APs everywhere, life as an admin is likely to get ugly.

Plan as if you were using 10Meg Hubs. Where you have groups of PCs together, use a WGB. If the area design allows for it, you may want to implement some VLANs.

There is no generic answer except "It depends." It depends on your traffic loads, your budget, your expertise (or available expertise), the layout of the building, the PCs & printers you intend to connect .... the list goes on and on.

Try a design as if the APs were 10meg hubs, then do a site survey to see what coverage will be like for the local areas. Then change your design and survey again ... repeat as necessary.

It might be worthwhile to do a pilot in a non-critical area ... then you can baseline and monitor the setup to get a "real life" version of whether or not the wireless system will work for you ... or at least what adaptations may need to be made.

FWIW

Scott

Good stuff! Thanks

Review Cisco Networking for a $25 gift card