02-08-2025
08:43 PM
- last edited on
02-08-2025
11:27 PM
by
shaiksh
hello to everyone
I am pretty confused about MSTP multiple regions.
Why do we use multiple regions in MSTP? What is the requirement for?
IS it good to do in order to bring load balancing in LAN switching?
what is the disadvantage of using MSTP multiple regions?
02-09-2025 06:22 AM
Hello
TBH there is no real requirement to have multiple mst or mst and non mst regions although they can be incurred in various ways though.
Such as when you need to join different switching domains together (merger of companies) or when you have migration of a non mst spanning-tree mode to mst, these will create separate spanning-tree domains
The links between these stp domains are called boundaries and you can have multiple redundant boundary interconnected links between different regions but LB wouldnt really viable, for these boundary interconnections need to run over a special spanning tree called CST (common spanning tree)
This CST which isn’t configurable but it is used by spanning-tree to allow communication for the differing stp domains to interact between each other in a consistent manner so they can elect the port state/roles of each boundary switch and more importantly which stp domain will become the root for the entire stp estate as role referred to as a CIST root.
So having multiple stp domains id say would be a disadvantage as most probably you would not have a full administrative control over the entire switching estate, plus you would obviously be running separate stp regions/ modes/mst instances etc...so as ive stated LB wouldn’t really be a viable option.
Furthermore if your just in a migration process say hardware and stp mode refresh then really you wouldn’t want to have any redundant physical links between the old/new stp domains (excluding aggregate ports)
you would just filter stp as a whole on its single boundary link whilst the migration is in process, this will isolate either stp domain but would not cause any stp changes within either domain but still allow communication between regions.
02-09-2025 06:41 AM
@Nader ibrahimi Multiple MSTP regions are used when you need to scale your Layer 2 network while maintaining control over spanning tree instances. Each region can have its own independent MST instances (MSTIs), reducing the overall STP complexity compared to running a separate STP instance per VLAN.
Using multiple MSTP regions can help with load balancing by allowing different VLANs to take different paths across the network. However, this requires careful planning of instance-to-VLAN mapping and the placement of root bridges.
The main disadvantage of multiple MSTP regions is that inter-region communication relies on the Common Spanning Tree (CST), which treats each region as a single entity. This can lead to suboptimal path selection, potential bottlenecks at region boundaries, and increased complexity in troubleshooting.
02-09-2025 06:58 AM
Hello
@vishalbhandari wrote:
Using multiple MSTP regions can help with load balancing by allowing different VLANs to take different paths across the network.
The main disadvantage of multiple MSTP regions is that inter-region communication relies on the Common Spanning Tree (CST), which treats each region as a single entity
why would you do this and how would you LB between regions?
Also in a single region you would have at most 2 MSTis , I cannot see why you would need for more than that as its per instance stp NOT per vlan stp so you will not manually prunning any trunks or setting prioirties on individual vlans
02-16-2025 08:24 AM
Hi Nader
There are two points
1- instance
2- region
Instance use to load balance between multilink in same region by block/forward some vlan
Region is only number add to give ID to mstp domain' i.e. three SW run one mst will have one region which can connect to other SW run different region number.
MHM
Discover and save your favorite ideas. Come back to expert answers, step-by-step guides, recent topics, and more.
New here? Get started with these tips. How to use Community New member guide