The good thing about MGCP is that allows you control both the incoming DIDs and the dial-plan for them at CUCM. The gives you a centralized management which reduces administration costs. If the router that terminates the T1 does not currently terminate any other SIP/H323 trunk (I am not referring only to trunks to the ITSP but, for example, to other PBXs) I would go with MGCP.
Should you change in the future to SIP, the changes, regarding the CUCM-router part, are not that big.
Georgios
Please rate if you find this helpful.