cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
5641
Views
5
Helpful
6
Replies
Highlighted
Contributor

ATA-187 vs. VG-202

Hello friends - I need some "specific use" scenarios to justify the expense of a VG-202 gateway over an ATA-187 when supporting analog devices.  I've been through the datasheets (which don't differ much, detail-wise - one supports SIP-only), and colleagues, which expressed a concern over the ATA's ability to support advanced faxing protocols (again, not in the datasheets).

The VG-202 is more than 2x the list price of the ATA-187.  I'll be presenting soon to the customer, and need to understand the specific reasons why the VG would be required.  Again, I need a few specific case examples where the VG-202 would do the job, and the ATA-187 would NOT.

Thanks, folks!

1 ACCEPTED SOLUTION

Accepted Solutions
Highlighted

OK, I'll bite (again)

The only reason you'd use a VG202 over an ATA is administration.

VGs run IOS, so are nice and easy to administer for your average Cisco engineer. IOS also makes troubleshooting easier too.

The ATAs, *sigh* aren't so administrator friendly.

GTG

Please rate all helpful posts.

View solution in original post

6 REPLIES 6
Highlighted
Engager

We've got lots of ATA186s. When the VG202 came out, we bought one to test. So far, we've yet to find a reason why we need a VG202 over an ATA.

Regarding faxes: providing you use fax-pass through, there's nothing an ATA can't handle.

I hope this helps.

GTG

Please rate all helpful posts.
Highlighted

I appreciate your input, Gordon, and good to know. There have to be specific reasons to justify the VG over the ATA, though. I'll hold the thread open for hopefully some additional perspective.

Thanks again

Highlighted

OK, I'll bite (again)

The only reason you'd use a VG202 over an ATA is administration.

VGs run IOS, so are nice and easy to administer for your average Cisco engineer. IOS also makes troubleshooting easier too.

The ATAs, *sigh* aren't so administrator friendly.

GTG

Please rate all helpful posts.

View solution in original post

Highlighted
Contributor

bump

Highlighted
Beginner

bump

Highlighted

Seems to me that you have been answered quite satisfactorly.

You can compare the data sheets of the two products and learn in first person what they do and how.

Content for Community-Ad